Talana, 1 Harcourt St, Hawthorn East, VIC


[Previous Post: Annesley, Mt Lawley .... Next Post: ]
Talana, Hawthorn East Queen Anne trophy home finally sells
Talana, Hawthorn East Queen Anne trophy home finally sells


1 Harcourt St, Hawthorn East, is on the market for $18 - $19.8m.

Samantha Landy, Herald Sun MAY 10, 201712:56PM
There is no shortage of period features in the home. Source:Supplied
There is no shortage of period features in the home. Source:Supplied


"ONE of Hawthorn East’s grandest homes is back on the market with a price guide as lofty as its towering facade"

  • "The spectacular mansion at 1 Harcourt Street Hawthorn has hit the market with a guide price of $18-$19.8 million — almost 10 times what it sold for in the year 2000, before it had been renovated.
  • The two-storey stunner sold for $2 million in 2000, and more recently for $10.799 million in 2014 after a 1010-day stint on the market, according to CoreLogic. It was fully renovated between the sales.
  • These records show one expansive update outdoor with a permit for a $69,520 swimming pool issued in December 2004."[1]

Talana is the most elaborate Queen Anne residence in Melbourne.


"The house is extremely large."
  • "The two storey height is emphasised by an extra high ground floor, a raised plinth above ground level, and the large hipped roof."
  • "Executed in the required red brick, the decorative embellishments are in render and rough cast, overlaid with timber."
  • "Although the house has a basic gable wing, to coordinate point form, it departs from the standard Queen Anne pattern in several areas:
    • Tower. Porch & Verandah
      The principal facade to Harcourt Street has (overlaid on the basic form), a tower and entry porch gable feature and the return verandah is a highly individual design.
    • Bay Window & Tower Window: The corner bay expression in the verandah is atypical and the Gothic tracery in the tower window unusual on a Queen Anne design.
  • "The roof is clad with Marseilles tiles. Given their date, these are probably of imported French origin along with the cappings and griffon.
    • Although the building addresses the corner site with its corner balcony, the principal facade is clearly Harcourt Street.
    • The grounds provide an appropriate context for the building but do not contain a garden which makes a contribution on its own."

  • NOT heritage protected by Victorian Heritage
  • Indicative listing only with the Australian Heritage Register
  • HO247 Overlay for External Controls, Boroondara Planning Scheme
    Talana is the most elaborate Queen Anne residence in Melbourne
    Talana is the most elaborate Queen Anne residence in Melbourne

A substantially intact mansion which is a landmark in Auburn Road and Harcourt Street. The last of Beswicke's mansions here and the gateway building to the mansion house precinct in Harcourt Street. - Aust Heritage Register

Talana was designed by renowned Melbourne architect John Beswicke, who was responsible for the Hawthorn, Malvern, Essendon, Dandenong and Brighton town halls, and other significant properties, including ‘Rotha’, a few doors down at 29 Harcourt Street.
  • Talana was originally designed by Beswicke for his family to live in, but the move didn’t eventuate.
  • Beswicke’s designs began in the 1870s and were constructed mostly for his own family - including
external image hTpUTZp3yI6Kuxc7rOtVeu7PrvOqrxRiUx4CDDuR8vyO9McFRul9g0kSzW14QPQskNFizrUthYosuClUKoKduUBhc3W8fRiXyw4vu8xTP85JCOzFQPzcEhgmj1wAQJBdPwUg2hOqMig1w4KFf7N2r0bs4kEsk9Hy5q_Hc5z1u3z70tC5Ib2XuIIfjJMk7v7rgMsdwH6kqggfd-ZHGACoUO4i4SwdUEo8dGwheqpj6-noRmd-5O901FDimDG_NR87DyDS4BN8NKtoEHNJ172siYremyVPsL7Eah1HDXIbR1pTuEPA-GxVcU-FWapaqXpt2VGPG0m_Bxmsmb1r_LMtkjMoRB2YKlGETtjMTYpYkkDQuTPkEGagwBoEWYXl7uBIDz2vWYg7TjbXdAq6cOBaEuaqXRs9joRsFgVe3L_OfTpFdL-sXhM90V6hmXhXeexT7irZDXmrN332YFfE3v3gqL8w2Hg5_OIsmWZphmMjEu82KhxXPEkqikn4g5j1iiHwshPeW6fLQVuwa8_lO6YgsPhiJUrDVzVNh1cJ94pNCnmTtIqIJUWB9XD3tSjPmU4wacPq2-Lby51esxT_lz5xoTrBDRTZEkgqHrwrhQiK6SREW7V56F5iTA=w700-h425-no
Former selling agent Andrew Harlock, of Abercromby’s Real Estate in Armadale, described Beswicke’s design as “freelance Federation Queen Anne architecture”, which was unlikely to be repeated.
  • “It’s a triple-brick home. To build that today would be just astronomical price-wise,” Mr Harlock said. “You just wouldn’t build a house like that again today. Mr Harlock said large allotments in Harcourt St were rarely sold.”[2]

1 AUGUST 2014 - Jonathan Chancellor - Property Observer

Talana, Hawthorn East Queen Anne trophy home finally sells


Talana, the imposing Queen Anne-style residence at Hawthorn East, has been sold by lawyer Tony Troiani, a partner at King & Wood Mallesons.
  • Set on Harcourt Street, the six-bedroom, three-bathroom 1900 house was designed by architect John Beswicke, the best known architect in Hawthorn during the late 1800s, having also designed the Hawthorn Town Hall.
  • The red-brick house, with the decorative embellishments overlaid with timber, comes with a third-storey tower under the large hipped roof clad in Marseilles tiles.
  • Having been listed with Marshall White in 2011, it was relisted through RT Edgar agent Michael Ebeling with $11 million-plus hopes in 2012.

  • The most recent marketing agents were Abercromby's who marketed it as offering a resort style family lifestyle with six bedrooms and three bathrooms, a tennis court with golf driving nets, enormous dual-heated lap/leisure pool, and an extra fully self-contained, Boston Ivy-clad summer house.

  • Jock Langley of Abercromby’s real estate was expecting about $10 million.[3]

  • The Talana mansion sits on an acre at the beginning of Harcourt Street, just south of Barkers Road.
    The Talana mansion sits on an acre at the beginning of Harcourt Street, just south of Barkers Road.

"Talana is a perfect example of a Victorian Federation mansion.

  • Built at the beginning of the Federation style’s proliferation in 1900, Talana in Hawthorn possesses some strong Tudor influences that carried over from the late 19th century.
  • The mansion sits on an acre at the beginning of Harcourt Street, just south of Barkers Road.
  • Harcourt St is a bit of an anomaly in Hawthorn East, as it’s about a one kilometre stretch of High Victorian, Boom Time, and Federation mansions on extremely large (one acre +) lots that’s remained safe from subdivision (until now)."
  • "The enormous block sizes and the desirable location were the key features in what was in effect a speculative mansion house development, promoted by the Beswicke family."[4]
Talana, 1 Harcourt St, Hawthorn East, VIC
Talana, 1 Harcourt St, Hawthorn East, VIC


Photography via "Radical Terrace: Federation Friday"

external image tumblr_lxp4b3d8qC1r72jxso2_250.jpgexternal image tumblr_lxp4b3d8qC1r72jxso3_250.jpgexternal image tumblr_lxp4b3d8qC1r72jxso4_250.jpg

external image tumblr_lxp4b3d8qC1r72jxso5_250.jpgexternal image tumblr_lxp4b3d8qC1r72jxso6_250.jpgexternal image tumblr_lxp4b3d8qC1r72jxso7_250.jpg

external image tumblr_lxp4b3d8qC1r72jxso8_250.jpgexternal image tumblr_lxp4b3d8qC1r72jxso9_250.gifexternal image tumblr_lxp4b3d8qC1r72jxso10_250.png


Subdivision land sale along nearby Higham Road in 1900
Subdivision land sale along nearby Higham Road in 1900

Harcourt Street, Hawthorn


At the turn of the century, Harcourt Street offered a unique pocket of grand Victorian living.
  • Unlike Toorak, where large estates still existed unfettered and with hefty distances between them, Harcourt Street provided its residents with a unified streetscape of imposing, but consistent housing stock.
  • The above MMBW map reveals Victorian and Federation Free Style homes of comparable size as existed in the contemporaneous suburbs of Malvern and Hawthorn but on far deeper lots, enabling Harcourt Street homes to rest on imposing gardens. According to the aforementioned Hawthorn Heritage Study:
Recognising the prime hill top location and the genteel reputation Hawthorn had acquired, the Harcourt Street area was amongst the first land to be redivided after the Government block land sales.
  • The enormous block sizes and the desirable location were the key features in what was in effect a speculative mansion house development, promoted by the Beswicke family.
  • Harcourt Street quickly became a fashionable address.
  • Development in Auburn Road and Lyndhurst Crescent capitalized on the existing image to consolidate this region as a highly desirable Victorian period suburb for the wealthy.
  • In contrast, the adjoining Rathmines Village area to the south, developed on the back of the mansion houses with small servicing quarters (Rathmines Grove) and more modest but respectable housing for the middle class. …[This area is of] local significance for the illustration of the flow on effect of early mansion house construction on the type of construction in the surrounding area, creating nodes of high status housing on hills, and is typical of the mixed Hawthorn character elsewhere.[5]

'Talana' - a historic manor of grand proportion on 4,198m2


"Exemplifying exquisite craftsmanship and peerless detail that is rarely seen today, this historic c1900 Queen Anne Federation mansion 'Talana' offers a unique modern luxury across its sprawling floorplan of lovingly-preserved period splendour.
  • Positioned on approx. 4,198m2 (45,187ft2), the triple-brick manor offers 5 bedroom plus study accommodation and abundant living and dining spaces,
  • in addition there is a self-contained one-bedroom summer house that lies between a sparkling azure pool and full-size synthetic tennis court in the midst of pristine lush and leafy landscaping, granting the sentiment of a grand country estate."[6]
Talana, 1 Harcourt St, Hawthorn East, VIC
Talana, 1 Harcourt St, Hawthorn East, VIC
Designed by renowned 19th-century architect John Beswicke, the towering Tudor-style façade is enriched with its Marseille roofing and ornate cappings, a broad tessellated-tile encircling verandah, and Gothic-arched entry.
  • Internally, an expansive foyer introduces the elaborate chandeliers, intricate leadlights, embellished fireplaces, and gleaming polished jarrah floorboards that flood the ground floor, beneath dizzyingly high ceilings boasting a rare and superlative ornate detail.
  • Original features of the property have been retained, including stained-glass windows, ornate ceilings and fireplaces.
  • The meticulously-restored home has five bedrooms, dining rooms, sitting rooms, a home theatre and its very own “tower room”.[7]
external image qjgulZewszHeXpyOUV4Bq_EXHDD4gqVeVwpsVDW6viKDc98qi5L3NW1WX_RE7Jwp4NS3NRjIHydMMXo=w120-h90-rwexternal image nGDTVPE-Z4UMBBdzo-Y4O3Xzx450vSU8IYj9yiNkYbTL75Ks_J2YCNN_tLishtU8leXSCmp7_1mdAOU=w120-h90-rwexternal image Ee4oGL1ZGqfUQPAaCNHJiKJUtrpLHpktWpUOn4DW7yJuiR8MJhhH27obTfcZAtOOE2FTebS__5WNu7o=w120-h90-rwexternal image 9noAwJDXgkMzMwiasaeV5Bf0L2eH-8kkWpCmItF5Imxf29i5nAeGeFZHZLbZoXG2Q_8PE7MfF7AGVIk=w120-h90-rwexternal image owrRmWskBRX_6l2N0e2LeqDL3e5f_ePsIVulVPO2LJRvyMQBGvxE6_scSzzx95YtKAHOh6uFUBnSNdk=w120-h90-rwexternal image TL1oJGLDOQdb3vhB3Wzmwsi0Dni6kobjno6wNnDuQ4lBeUytA08bUtQ0Iye_Tr91hAoc-iNnuJTwF9Q=w120-h90-rw external image CE60X9SlfUPoa0E74ABKf7XJl9K9RX2MzLLpgcvTDlK9Sv_X4rfnX5CJUDGv0yaXwNZJ-gjvxrwOuaw=w120-h90-rwexternal image 39gvdz3p5YcauBTt90WJ4eCZ4nYf2boEGn_V0yFLWxw69dQv7ZWS5yYwTKL6dJ1zpNtKunNfB27n72M=w120-h90-rwexternal image OFatV0gjJcTeoKzDFqjWOW4Y97uThSxdl2HdztP8fWqMP2ZE5oXuFH2jDHmkZwa7VNqmVih4hj5QSOE=w120-h90-rwexternal image D1_FG-KdPucRVoQmmvfuAyvCJyDcdADpmslMQB-7vLlO3qeguEghTRpVlHuFyRxLKUcXLZsQf9pddI0=w120-h90-rwexternal image qmljxamZm-tGqEYsV3ykB6bPlLQQ9dtyHPBqRdAWFMq6BN7ab10Xg6a9Pe1RaS4hnqPV32Hkn8GvuvQ=w120-h90-rwexternal image cH68K1kuJnpxIujF_-QYDoa4s8T6OHCa5mMYN-92ef4Q5prinNHh8YEdlf5op4aeim8tXHpw4N3o7aY=w120-h90-rw external image w90NZYRvIkLC5QlEXGZgPwDpcyrODVXdlpJlIzaPJiXR958SShJGx0FUmkVh4yUQfa95X4F_Ezvysxw=w120-h90-rwexternal image DR7j9qimar9OOFUSaRN4-V4pyH2Z1221oQI6gL6x1FMW6ZtMGCAGqzs4jXBpa72l8MLssEdTXFheRZw=w120-h90-rwexternal image YRi8Mf7zg8VH92q4Gdkx5gaLZ9TjXAXtW-rABV1T6idNKKZOkqckf8r1eeydA_0U1d1zgfBb6qksh_I=w120-h90-rwexternal image klI3Ke44iObcb1EHfvxqIwqnb6GNEIP3SadF9vuYGmKx5Q5El871iXM9TevJzo8fcn4ZnjuWA7KRdv4=w120-h90-rwexternal image jDntVFG4XIodne6KifQPKL1B83YL2Vze__14Er2Pnzcdggdh4iICw5Tu0hcwfP_9f69DNYmHNTrgL-o=w120-h90-rwexternal image q2exoYk7seFx3Tx1ziGPxXtYPSqvsa0YGmfXNd7sTEPOvqd1mJDKzBAbkSodVrn3_7RxEDbwHXtj7vA=w120-h90-rw

History of Talana and its owners


The historic Talana in Melbourne was first listed for sale with Marshall White in April 2011 with hopes of selling for $12 million plus. It didn’t.
  • In April of 2012, the house was re-listed with RT Edgar at a slightly reduced price of $10 million (according to PriceFinder data), but by the end of August the home no longer appeared on any listing sites. It is possible that the seller, perhaps frustrated with the lack of activity on the home, did not renew their listing agreement and has taken it off the market.

Talana, named after a town in the province of Ogliastra, Sardinia, Italy, was built in 1899 – 1900 for the Jones family.
  • It was designed by architect John Beswicke, renowned for his work in Hawthorn during the late 1800s which included the Hawthorn Town Hall and two other grand homes in Harcourt Street (Rotha – his own residence, and Tudor Lodge – later renamed Hilton House).
  • The house was built in the “Village of Rathmines” subdivision which was developed by landowner James Murphy from the mid-1850s. It originally contained 112 blocks of about one acre each.
  • Talana is one of the original surviving mansions from the subdivision. It is located on Harcourt Street, which is known for its concentration of 19th century mansions with expansive grounds.
  • Original house records show that it was owned by Mrs. Annie A. Jones, with James C. Jones, warehouseman, listed as the occupying tenant in 1900.[8]

From The Radical Terrace:
The initial subdivision of land in this pocket of Hawthorn East occurred in the midst of the Gold Rush. According to a 1993 Hawthorn Heritage Study:
  • With the separation of Victoria from the mother colony of New South Wales and the beginning of the gold-rush era in 1851, the price of colonial land dropped and, as a consequence, there was an increased demand for Hawthorn allotments by eager speculators. The value of these purchases trebled in the next few years. Most notable was James Murphy’s purchase of allotment 70, 124 acres on the north west corner of Burke and Barkers Road, which became known as Murphy’s Paddock. This was later carved up by Murphy in a mid-1850s private subdivision into the Village of Rathmines Estate, which included the important Harcourt Street area…

Harcourt Street’s staying power since its first subdivision during the Gold Rush years of the 19th Century owes, in part, to the highly rectangular blocks of land. In 1857, we were able to dig up the below parcel map that reveals Harcourt Street’s subdivision (between what is now Barkers Road and Rathmines Road, but what was then referred to as 'Westmoreland Street’ and the unnamed 'Government Road’). The area between Auburn Road and Kildare Street - the most prestigious pocket of 1k long road owing to its elevated views - was subdivided into twelve just-shy-of-2-acre blocks of land.
The first subdivision of Harcourt Street in 1857, then referred to as 'Village of Rathmines’.
The first subdivision of Harcourt Street in 1857, then referred to as 'Village of Rathmines’.


Of these original twelve, only one home retains its original parcel size (#5, although even that estate chopped off a small portion of its backyard for the inter-war subdivision of the Maurice Street cul-de-sac at the property’s rear). Even Talana, the show-stopping Federation at the entrance to the road siphoned off three properties (1A and 3 Harcourt Street, 25 Auburn Road) at various times. But that’s a digression. It is unclear to the Radical Terrace how many homes were developed during the Gold Rush era - likely very few - but by the end of the Land Boom of the 1880s, architect John Beswicke’s Italianate designs proliferated on slightly reduced blocks.[9]


References



  1. ^ http://www.news.com.au/finance/real-estate/melbourne-vic/hawthorn-east-manor-on-the-market-for-almost-20-million/news-story/231cccb2ab7794c2b9a63b73a4ee8038
  2. ^ http://www.heraldsun.com.au/leader/inner-east/hawthorn-east-105m-beswicke-property-at-risk-of-subdivision-for-sale-option/news-story/b4869ed61f17f0228f0d8489b04e1c90
  3. ^
  4. ^ http://radicalterrace.com/post/43408881839/another-harcourt-street-listing-emerges-with
  5. ^ http://radicalterrace.com/post/43408881839/another-harcourt-street-listing-emerges-with
  6. ^ https://www.domain.com.au/1-harcourt-street-hawthorn-east-vic-3123-2013567988
  7. ^ http://www.heraldsun.com.au/leader/inner-east/hawthorn-east-105m-beswicke-property-at-risk-of-subdivision-for-sale-option/news-story/b4869ed61f17f0228f0d8489b04e1c90
  8. ^ https://oldestatesforsale.wordpress.com/2012/09/01/talana-on-again-off-again/
  9. ^


    http://radicalterrace.com/post/43408881839/another-harcourt-street-listing-emerges-with